Underage drinking is a serious concern in Massachusetts. Parents often wonder: if their child or a group of teens is caught drinking, can the parents themselves face criminal charges or civil lawsuits? It isn’t just a hypothetical worry but a situation that plays out in courtrooms every year across the state. Speaking with a Massachusetts Criminal Defense Lawyer can help families better understand the risks and their legal options.
The consequences are not limited to the kids. Under social host law, parents themselves may face fines, jail time, and even lawsuits if alcohol is consumed by minors on property they control. Yet the law is not always straightforward. There is one narrow exception, and many families misunderstand where the line is drawn.
This post explains how the law works, what penalties parents may face, and the limited circumstances where exceptions apply.
Massachusetts Underage Drinking Laws
State law makes it illegal to furnish alcohol to anyone under 21 or to allow minors to drink on property you control.
General Laws c.138 §34: Whoever furnishes alcohol to a person under 21 years of age, or knowingly allows such person to possess alcohol on premises under his control, shall be punished by a fine of not more than $2,000 or by imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.
In practice, this means that if a parent hosts a gathering where teens are drinking—even without physically handing them the alcohol, they may still be charged.
There are also laws targeting minors directly. MGL c.138 §34C prohibits anyone under 21 from possessing or transporting alcohol, with fines and potential driver’s license suspensions through the Registry of Motor Vehicles. View statute.
Additionally, Massachusetts enforces a zero-tolerance BAC standard of 0.02% for drivers under 21. Even a small amount of alcohol can result in an OUI (Operating Under the Influence) charge.
Parental Liability: Criminal and Civil
Parents can face two types of exposure when minors drink: criminal penalties under the statute and civil liability if harm occurs.
Criminal liability arises when a parent knowingly provides alcohol to minors or allows possession on property they control. This can include a home, vacation rental, or even a hotel room booked in their name.
Civil liability is separate and potentially more damaging. If a minor who consumed alcohol at a parent’s property later causes an accident or injury, the parent can be sued under social host liability rules. Courts have consistently allowed lawsuits against hosts for damages linked to underage drinking incidents.
Seasonal events such as prom parties, graduation celebrations, and summer gatherings are common contexts where both criminal charges and lawsuits arise.
Exceptions and Legal Gray Areas
The law does recognize a narrow exception for parents in their own home.
Massachusetts Jury Instruction 7.410 clarifies that the statute does not prohibit a parent from furnishing alcohol to their own child in the parent’s home.
This means a mother or father may legally give a drink to their 20-year-old son or daughter in the family kitchen. But the exception is limited. It does not extend to other minors. If a teen guest drinks at the same house, the parent may still be charged.
Another gray area involves property a parent controls but does not occupy. For example, if teens drink in a hotel room or rental arranged by a parent, liability can follow. Courts generally look at who had authority or control over the premises when alcohol was consumed.
Penalties and Real-World Consequences
The penalties under MGL c.138 §34 are not minor. Parents convicted can face:
- A fine of up to $2,000.
- Jail time of up to one year.
- A permanent criminal record that may affect employment or licensing.
The consequences do not stop with criminal court. Parents may also face:
- Civil lawsuits from injured parties.
- Increased insurance premiums or coverage disputes.
- Emotional and reputational damage in the community.
According to campaigns such as “Parents Who Host Lose the Most,” a single incident can create lasting financial and personal consequences.
Table: Criminal vs. Civil Liability for Parents in Massachusetts
|
Aspect
|
Criminal Liability (MGL c.138 §34) |
Civil Liability (Social Host Doctrine)
|
| Who can be charged? |
Parents/guardians/adults furnishing or allowing |
Parents, homeowners, or property controllers |
| Penalties |
Up to $2,000 fine and/or 1 year in jail |
Financial damages in lawsuits for injuries, accidents |
| Trigger |
Furnishing alcohol or allowing possession |
Injury/accident caused by minor after drinking |
| Exception |
Parent providing to own child at home |
None – civil exposure applies regardless |
Preventive Guidance for Parents
Parents often underestimate their exposure. Some assume that not handing out alcohol means no liability. But the law punishes both furnishing and knowingly allowing possession.
Ignorance is not always a defense. If the facts suggest parents should have known teens were drinking, charges can still follow. Hosting parties where alcohol is accessible, even indirectly, puts families at risk.
Practical prevention tips include:
- Communicate firm household rules about underage drinking.
- Supervise teen gatherings and secure alcohol in the home.
- Avoid lending property or space for unsupervised parties.
Civil exposure is another reason for caution. Homeowner’s or umbrella insurance may cover some claims, but alcohol-related incidents are often excluded. Families cannot rely on insurance as protection.
Get Your Free Consultation
FAQs
Can parents be arrested if their teen drinks in their own home?
Parents can be arrested if other minors drink at home. Exception applies only when parents provide alcohol solely to their own child.
What happens if a teen leaves a party and causes an accident?
Parents or hosts may face lawsuits under social host liability. Civil damages can include medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
Is ignorance a defense if parents “didn’t know” minors were drinking?
Not always. If evidence shows parents should have known alcohol was present, prosecutors may still pursue charges under social host law.
Are there consequences for the minors themselves?
Yes. Minors risk fines, license suspensions, or criminal charges for possession, transport, or operating a vehicle under the influence.
Can minors also be charged as social hosts?
Yes. Massachusetts courts have ruled that minors can face the same charges if they furnish alcohol or host gatherings with underage drinking.
Does homeowner’s insurance cover social host lawsuits?
Sometimes, but many policies exclude alcohol-related claims. Families should not assume coverage applies to underage drinking incidents.
Conclusion
Parents in Massachusetts face real risks when minors are caught drinking. Criminal penalties under MGL c.138 §34 include fines and jail, while civil lawsuits may follow if harm occurs. The only narrow exception allows a parent to serve alcohol to their own child in their own home. Beyond that, both criminal and civil exposure is significant.
Understanding these rules is the first step in prevention. Families should set clear boundaries, supervise gatherings, and avoid situations where minors might drink on their property. If charges do arise, experienced legal guidance is essential.
Riccio Law provides defense for individuals and families navigating Massachusetts criminal laws, including social host liability and underage drinking cases. If you or your family are facing charges, professional representation can help protect your rights and future.
